Selective Corrective Feedback

-
TESL 0110
Unit 3 Reflection
Teachers should be selective when correcting students' mistakes. This appears to be a topic that is hotly debated. According to Scott Thornbury's true or false quiz on myths and misconceptions about corrective feedback, this statemement is false. I  completely disagreed with Thornbury's answer to this question. I don't think it is beneficial to a student's learning or self-esteem to point out every single mistake that they make, in any skill area. If a student has many errors and they are all identified, it may be overwhelming and the student may not be able to process the amount of information they are being told. As a result, they are not likely to learn from those mistakes or correct them in future speaking or writing tasks. In addition, pointing out all of a student's errors can have a negative effect on their self-worth. It can crush their self-confidence and cause them to not want to do further tasks. It may also result in them only using structures that they are familiar with and not wanting to take risks, which is an important part of learning. The point of corrective feedback is for students to learn from their mistake, internalize the information, and transfer that learning to future tasks so that they do not repeat the same mistakes over and over again. It is a learning process.
It is interesting that there isn't a definitive answer and that research shows conflicting views on the selectivity of corrective feedback in writing.  In the written feedback techniques section in Mistakes and feedback by Harmer, he talks about focusing, which is when we "restrict feedback to a particular aspect of language." This method allows students to concentrate their attention on specific written features. In A Typology of written corrective feedback, Ellis states that focused corrective feedback "may prove more effective as the learner is able to examine multiple corrections of a single error and thus obtain the rich evidence they need to both understand why what they wrote was erroneous and to acquire the correct form." (p.102) Our professor, Ana, shared a summary on the topic from Alister Cumming, professor emeritus at OISE. (A. Bartosik, personal communication, November 20, 2018). According to Cumming, to be effective, error correction should be selective and focused on a few specific items that were taught. I am in complete agreement.
I think being selective with corrective feedback is ideal, and I have often done so in elementary and middle school classrooms in my past professional experience. Identifying a specific writing feature, and letting the students know that is what you will be focusing on, will result in students focusing their attention on that aspect of their writing. Then when they receive their corrective feedback they can see what they need to work on within that particular written feature. In the next writing piece I can focus on something else, unless of course the students need additional practice with that writing feature. In my opinion and from my experience, selective corrective feedback is necessary for learning and transfer to occur.
References:

Ellis, R. (April, 2009). A typology of written corrective feedback. ELT Journal, V63, n2.
Harmer, J. (2001). Chapter 7: Mistakes and feedback . In Harmer, J. (Eds.), The practice of English language teaching (pp. 99-104 & 109-113). Essex, England: Longman.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Continued Professional Development Report

-
Image
TESL 0170 Practicum in Teaching ESL The professional development resource that I selected to engage with and analyze is the free online CLB Bootcamp provided by the Centre for Canadian Language Benchmarks. The CLB Bootcamp is a 10-hour self-directed online training course that introduces and explains the CLB’s, as well as how to use the CLB’s for lesson planning and student assessment. The CLB Bootcamp is divided into three modules: CLB Basics , Planning and the CLB and Classroom Assessment and the CLB . Each module is then broken down into three to four sections. The material is presented in a format similar to a PowerPoint presentation, with links to resources, documents and example materials. There are also optional short quizzes throughout that can be taken more than once. It is not necessary to complete the sections or modules in order, or even to complete them all. You can pick and choose which areas you want to learn more about. If you do complete all of the modules...
Read more

My Classroom Community

-
Image
TESL 0100 So I kind of overlooked this assignment, or maybe I was procrastinating it and avoiding it because I am not much of an artist and was not really looking forward to attempting to draw my classroom. :) I tried to do some of the parts in 3D, but other parts are much more basic. It's kind of a mix of both. Attempting to draw a couch was the trickiest part! Anyways, I like to think of my classroom as a community of learners, which is why I used a circular table with me, the teacher (the one with the speech bubble), as part of the circle. When needed, everyone can turn their chairs toward the whiteboard for direct instruction, or to read sentence stems or discussion prompts. I would put our agenda on the board so the students would know what was in store for the day. There would also be a word wall bulletin board with high frequency words and words we had learned in previous lessons. The classroom would have a bookshelf with a wide variety of reading materials and games/...
Read more

21st Century Learners

-
Image
TESL 0100 Unit 9 Reflection As we begin to think about the language classroom that we may be teaching in, we need need to also take a step back and consider what teaching and learning looks like in the twenty-first century. We were asked to think about the skills, tasks and technologies that our students would need to have an understanding of in order to be successful in today's world, and to create an infographic to represent our ideas. Below is the infographic that I created. It includes the skills and strategies that I believe are needed by all students, including language students. In order to succeed in today's ever-changing world, students need to be taught more than just the basic knowledge and skills that were taught in traditional classroom. The four key skills that I have highlighted - communication, collaboration, creativity and critical thinking, often referred to as the four C's, should be an important component to any classroom. In university, the workp...
Read more